skeehorse Wrote:http://www.hotrod.com/how-to/engine/mopp...s-headers/
This is a interesting article
Hello Jim,
Comparing factory HP exhaust manifolds to full tube headers is like comparing apples to oranges, you just can't make that comparison. The two are engineered to achieve different objectives.
As I mentioned in one of my previous posts in this thread, if you're building a car to compete on the drag strip on a regular basis in the non street legal classes, then run a good set of headers, but for those folks who will be driving their cars on the street most of the time with only a few outings to the drag strip during the year, the HP manifolds are the way to go. If someone builds an engine for mostly street use with a parts package that is designed for that type of use, like many of our owners have done with their cars here on the DCR, then the HP manifolds will serve them very well without any of the issues that headers will give them. Some brands of headers pose less issues than others, but all headers no matter which brand they may be will cause some grief in one way or another because of the way they have to be designed.
My Coronet with the 440 that I built for it back in 1991 (that is still in place to this day) which is a fairly mild set-up, runs the HP exhaust manifolds along with 3" pipe and HP mufflers (completely street legal). This car was seriously drag raced in the N.H.R.A. street legal class from 1991 through 1997 and did very well and has run some high 12 second quarter mile passes in California's cooler weather while running consistent low 13 second quarter mile passes in the hot weather here in Arizona. Other than having the exhaust manifold mating surfaces checked to make sure that they were flat, along with having the cylinder heads and exhaust manifold ports machined for identical port sizes at the mating surfaces, nothing else was done to the HP manifolds other than a good cleaning. I truly believe that even quicker E.T.'s are possible with these HP manifolds if so desired.
The pro's of running HP exhaust manifolds?
(01) They were designed to fit our cars without having to make any modification to the car, no matter if the car is an automatic or a 4 speed equipped car and they also work with any other options that any given car may have including power steering, power brakes (disc, or drum), air conditioning and anything else you might have. There may need to be a minor modification to the exhaust system depending on the model year, because there is a slight difference in the angle on the manifolds where they meet up to the exhaust piping between the 1968 and 1969 manifolds from what I understand.
(02) You will not have any of the problems you will have with full length tube headers, which include but are not limited to the following.
(A) Poorly designed header flanges that warp which causes exhaust leaks
(B) Header bolts that will back out and become loose which will lead to exhaust leaks
© Difficult spark plug access
(D) Burnt spark plug wires and boots
(E) Thin wall header tubing that will rust out
(F) Added heat in the engine compartment
Will the HP manifolds be competitive with full length tube headers on a Dyno test? No, but how many of us Dyno test our street engines? Are you REALLY going to notice the horsepower decrease you will get with the HP manifolds while driving your car on the street? We want our street engines to be as trouble free as is possible with 50 year old technology while running well and sounding good and trust me, the factory HP manifolds will give you extremely easy installation with no modifications to the car, will give you years of trouble free operation and will sound fantastic depending on the rest of the exhaust system parts you use.
In closing Jim, I will say that the short tube headers shown in the article you posted do look much more promising, as it looks as if many of the problems associated with the full length tube headers are being addresses. I'd like to hear from some folks who are using those to get their feedback.
Richard